Detroit Creditors Not Allowed to Remove Art, Judge Rules

  • May 15, 2014 22:30

  • Email
rederic E. Church, Cotopaxi, 1862, oil on canvas, Detroit Institute of Arts, Founders Society Purchase, Robert H. Tannahill Foundation Fund, Gibbs-Williams Fund, Dexter M. Ferry Jr. Fund, Merrill Fund, Beatrice W. Rogers Fund, & Richard A. Manoogian Fund

Bankruptcy Judge Steven Rhodes ruled Thursday that Detroit's major creditors will not be allowed to remove artwork from the Detroit Institute of Arts in order to have it appraised.

The ruling is a blow to major bond insurers Syncora and Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. — who could collectively lose more than $1 billion in Detroit's bankruptcy. They want the city-owned artwork sold.

The DIA's attorney Arthur O'Reilly argued that removing the artworks could possibly cause damage. "All of that movement creates potential for risk. ... The very best way to keep art safe is to leave it in place," O'Reilly argued.


At the center of Thursday's proceedings was the creditors' view that the DIA's art has been undervalued in Detroit's reorganization plans. The $816-million, art-for-pensions "grand bargain" that would take funds from charitable foundations, the DIA and the state to help pay pensions while safegaurding DIA art from being sold is unfair, contend the creditors.

"We were hopeful that the City would cooperate fully with the four parties that expressed interest in entering into transactions that would fully monetize the Art," Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. said in a statement. "We maintain that the drastically undervalued DIA Settlement under the 'Grand Bargain' places politics over the financial and legal realities of the situation and will almost certainly result in drawn-out litigation that no one wants."

Read more at USA Today

  • Email

More News Feed Headlines

Detail: Marc Chagall, America Windows, 1977.  Art Institute of Chicago

For a Colorful Lift, Glimpse Chagall's America Windows

  • ArtfixDaily / July 5th, 2020

When the U.S. offered a safe harbor for refugees during World War II, Marc Chagall (1887-1985), the renowned ...

Monet's kitchen, Giverny

ARTFIXdaily Closed Week of June 29, Returns July 6

  • ArtfixDaily / June 27th, 2020

ARTFIXdaily will be closed the week of June 29. Subscriber e-newsletter service will resume July 6.

Watch Arthur Jafa’s powerful 7:25 minute video examination of Black life in America, Love is the Message, The Message is Death, which will be streamed by the Hirshhorn, Smithsonian and other museums from 2 p.m.  ET Friday, June 26 to 2 p.m.  ET Sunday, June 28.

Global Consortium of Museums Plan 48-Hour Stream of Artist Arthur Jafa’s Renowned “Love is the Message"

  • ArtfixDaily / June 25th, 2020

The Smithsonian American Art Museum and the Hirshhorn Museum and Sculpture Garden, in consultation with the artist ...

Ellsworth Kelly Oversized Postcard Set with matching stamps.

Art-Inspired Stamps to Buy Now to Support the USPS

  • ArtfixDaily / June 25th, 2020

Hit hard by impacts on first class and marketing mail volume during the pandemic shutdown, the largely self-funded ...

Spencer Helfen Fine Arts - Special Exhibition

ARTFIXdaily Artwire